Grantland

emily mortimer

Resize Font: A- A+

REVIEWS

Hot Air: Aaron Sorkin's Underwhelming Newsroom

By Andy Greenwald at
HBO

HBO has taken us to some fanciful places during its recent ratings resurgence, from the vampire-blood-stained bayou of True Blood to the violent kingdom of Westeros on Game of Thrones. But in terms of pure fantasy, neither holds a candle to The Newsroom, the new series from writer Aaron Sorkin and producer Scott Rudin. Although the program — which focuses on the backstage shenanigans at a popular cable news show — is ostensibly set in the real world, the true backdrop is one that should be familiar to fans of The West Wing (not to mention survivors of Studio 60). It’s pure Sorkinstan, an overwritten utopia where all names are alliterative, all dialogue is charged, and the call sheet runs wild with all manner of mythical creatures, including the Liberal Republican, the Gun-Toting Manhattan Lefty, and a preponderance of Twentysomethings Who Reference Musicals. But the biggest flight of fancy here is the one Sorkin seems most invested in: that television audiences are desperate not only to relive recent history, but to watch him attempt to pompously rewrite it.

Top Stories

MOST POPULAR

  1. Rating the lead singers of active bands in 2013
  2. A not-so-brief conversation with Damon Lindelof, the writer behind 'Lost,' 'Prometheus,' and 'Star T
  3. The Detroit Red Wings, Chicago Blackhawks, and Round 2 of the NHL playoffs
  4. Jonah Keri ranks the MLB teams
  5. The oral history of the 2003 World Series of Poker, in which Chris Moneymaker turned $39 into $2.5 m