Grantland

umpires

Resize Font: A- A+

MLB

Baseball Umpires' Nightly Nightmare

By Jonah Keri at

Minor league umpires are much like minor league players. When they finally get a chance to prove their stuff in the big leagues, they want to succeed. The biggest difference is, when a player gets the call he wants to do something spectacular to impress his bosses. The mark of a great umpire is when no one notices him at all.

Chris Conroy got noticed. Normally a Triple-A umpire, Conroy got called up as a vacation replacement for this week's Cubs-Cardinals series. He hadn't had many chances before — 16 games in 2011, just one in 2010. He'd been on the periphery for an egregiously bad call last year, when crew mate Phil Cuzzi awarded a three-ball walk to Cameron Maybin, who later came around to score the only run in a 1-0 Padres win. But for Conroy, a first-inning play at the plate Tuesday night was worse. Much worse.

Resize Font: A- A+

Unhappy Meals: Why Tuesday's Disputed Call Proves Nothing

Michael McKenry Julio Lugo
Scott Cunningham/Getty Images

He may have been safe.

I've watched the replay of Michael McKenry's attempted tag on Julio Lugo about 30 times. Replays from different angles. Still photos. Reenactments performed by trained chipmunks. Consensus has it that McKenry's swipe tag caught Lugo on the leg well in front of home plate. Given the Braves and Pirates had played six hours, 39 minutes and nearly 19 innings to that point, and that this game had major playoff implications for both teams, this was supposed to be a cruel, unjust, tragic way to end it. Worse than Jim Joyce's blowing the call that cost Armando Galarraga his perfect game. Given the technology at the disposal of everyone on the planet except the four umpires on the field, this is supposed to be a final, nail-in-the-coffin example of why baseball so desperately needs instant replay.

Top Stories